Pedestrian and Bikeway Advisory Committee - Sept. 1, 2026

Meeting materials

Attend the meeting

Free language assistance services are available for this meeting. Contact scotthoe@clackamas.us (48-hour notice needed).

Agenda

  • 6:30 p.m. – Welcome: Approval of Prior Meeting Minutes and Public Comment
  • 6:35 p.m. – 82nd Avenue Transit Project – TriMet
  • 6:55 p.m. – Clackamas County E-Bike Ordinance – Scott Hoelscher
  • 7:35 p.m. – TriMet Service Cuts –  Mya Ganzer & Scott Hoelscher
  • 7:45 p.m. – Hot Spots –  Committee 
  • 7:55 p.m. –Project Updates | For the Good of the Order |
  • 8:00 p.m. - Adjourn

Staff Liaisons:

Mya Ganzer • Planner 1• Dept. of Transportation & Development (503) 742-4520 • mganzer@clackamas.us

Scott Hoelscher • Senior Planner – Multimodal Transportation  • Dept. of Transportation & Development (503) 742-4533 • scotthoe@clackamas.us  

Minutes

Attendees: Bruce Parker, Del Scharffenberg, Dale Guenther, Dave Weber, Del Scharffenberg, Dick Weber, Jim Schroeder, Joseph Edge, Melinda Montecucco, Sheila Shaw, Vanessa Dane-Slagle

Mya Ganzer, Scott Hoelscher; Clackamas County

Brad Choi, Paulina Salgado; TriMet

Nicole Perry; SRTS/Street Trust

6:30 p.m. – Welcome: Approval of Prior Meeting Minutes and Public Comment

Bruce motions to approve June minutes

Vanessa seconds

No discussion

June minutes approved unanimously

6:34 p.m. – 82nd Avenue Transit Project – TriMet

Paulina Salgado: Replacing Line 72 (highest ridership route), new busses no bike front loading (like FX on Division), stops are being consolidated 0.3 miles apart near signalized crossings

Brad Choi: at 60% designs stage, final construction set (100% design) early next year, construction starting in Fall 2027 – 2029. 

Station platform will have similar platforms to FX on Division St. Stations are more similar to light rail systems, not typical bus stop. 

Stations between SE Lindy St and Clackamas Town Center Transit Center
Segment in Clackamas County

Intersections will be built out so they are ADA compliant, all of these will be updated with this project, except for Lindy St which is already compliant.

9 traffic signals in Clackamas County, transit signal priority for the bus.

Most of this segment has a curb tight bike line on 82nd, bus will pull into bike lane.

Community Engagement

  • One-on-one meetings with business/property owners with adjacent platform
  • Design concepts online in August
  • Neighborhood Association Meetings
  • In-person open house (September 16)
  • Community Event Tabling
    • Jade Night Market (August 29)
  • Direct Mail Outreach
    • Postcards to properties within a quarter-mile radius of 82nd highlighting changes, directing people to project website

King Rd, full bus pullout eliminating land blockages, shared bike lane symbol, will create a clearer interaction so bus drivers can take full advantage

Jim Schroeder: With all of the recent TriMet line service cuts, what is funding status of this project? 

Brad: This is a capital improvement funded project, service cuts are due to lack of general funds, from taxes. 

Jim: What nature or kind of signaling will the new buses be equipped with to notify cyclist in the bike lane that they are pulling out?

Brad: Bus drivers ave significant training and there is risk assessment to make sure there is not a conflict zone. I will reach out and follow up from our bus operating division. 

Jim: That’s okay, your response has indicated that you’re aware of the conflict and have taken measures to resolve it. 

Paulina: Join us for an in-person open house about project design

Wednesday, September 16, 5-7 p.m. COREPDX, 3612 SE 82nd Ave, Portland

6:55 p.m. – Clackamas County E-Bike Ordinance – Scott Hoelscher

Scott: It is not clear from County Counsel if the timing of our response can carry over into October. It’s short but legal ordinances are complicated. 

If E-bikes meet Class 1-3, they are classified as bicycles under state law. This does not include E-Motos, these might be marketed as e-bikes, but they are effectively mini motorcycles. There is a store in Clackamas County marketing e-motos as e-bikes. 

My comments include they don’t include information that e-motos in the whereas section unsafe operations. 

Dale: I disagree; I don’t think 28 mph is a safe speed for bicycle operation. 

Mindy: I recognize the Class 2 is 750 watts and top out at 20 mph, kids are hacking that and exceeding that speed. 

Sheila: Even when they are classified as e-bikes, kids are able to hack that.

Del: This document doesn’t mention the one wheel devices, the e-motos and one wheels terrorize me on bike paths, and there’s lots of unsafe users. 

Dale: we need to include one-wheels, and can we set speed limits lower the state rule?

Scott: I don’t think that would be enforceable and you’d telling people with bikes in the federal legal limit that they can’t operate at that speed. 

Dave: In Colorado they have a posted speed limit for bicycles, it’s very effective. 

Scott: I understood Dale’s question differently, as limiting the legal speed for the different classifications as e-bikes, is that correct?

Dale: You can modify the speed limit to go faster then what the classification allows. 

Scott: But vehicles can also exceed the speed limit, and even a road bike user could exceed 20 mph.

Sheila: Ultimately, I am interested in safety. I don’t think we should limit responsible e-bike users. We should limit those who are not using the e-bikes safely, like the kids on the trail I was walking 

Jim: We should add on something about fining those that exceed the manufacturers design. 7.08.030

The should use the same nomenclature for e-bike naming. 

Dale: Could federal and state law be cited here, and recommend variances for the county? 

Scott: Most of this is straight from the Oregon State Vehicle code. This all regulates behavior, so a lot of this bad behavior is already regulated in state law. 

Dale: it seems redundant, maybe we should remove it or cite straight to the state law. 

Jim: If we are using the state law, why are we retyping it all? When it changes, we will just be out of compliance with the ORS. 

Scott: Do we really want regulate e-bikes or illegal modified e-bikes and e-motos?

Del: I think we are focusing on is the wrong thing, I don’t have any problems with e-bikes, but with e-motos and stunt riders.

Mindy: We should mention any e-bikes tampered with is illegal? Do we care unless they are riding too fast?

Scott: That’s a good idea to add language on if they are hacked. 

Mindy: Maybe we add it number 2, and add it to the definitions. 

Del: there is any issue with the term manufactured for off road use. 

Sheila: we could add a definition in for “modified” Class 1/2/3 e-bikes, to define the tampered e-bikes. 

Scott: I think we are all in agreement that the issue is tampered e-bikes and the bad use.

Del: I have a negative view of the way they’re operated, not the vehicle itself.

Sheila: On Sunnyside Rd we see kids riding 3-4 abreast doing wheelies and unsafe behavior. 

Mindy: Single wheel ‘personal electric  vehicles (PEV). E-bikes. 
Many e-bike manufacturers  intentionally design their class 2 bikes with unlocked potential built into the software. Hence designed to be unlocked or via a companion app. 

I agree with Del. It’s the behavior that is dangerous.    

It’s not illegal to alter the e-bike yet

Dave: What is County’s objective? What is the most concerning part of it? But what's the most significant thing that is problematic for the potential lawful user of an e-bike in Clackamas County. That's the thing that I would look at.

Is there objective to make the space safer for people who are on paths and other places.

And so that's their objective. And they've written this long document attempting to do that.

We can wordsmith it. I mean, each one of us in our own way could probably rewrite this to be something that we thought was more meaningful, but a group activity like this is not going to happen in 10 or 15 minutes and give you anything meaningful in a short time frame, so…

My strong, strong suggestion for the crew is, what's the most, and you've read this a lot, Scott, what's the most important thing that we should ask them to change in this document? And the rest of it, I mean.

There are a number of errors in here, and we all pointed out, uh, different ones. But what's the most significant thing that is problematic for the potential lawful user of an e-bike in Clackamas County. That's the thing that I would look at.

Dale: I fully support your comments, Dave. I agree 100%. So, let's focus on that not on copying State code, but what is it we would like the county to do?

And from my standpoint, it's enforcement and penalties. And when the City of Happy Valley. there's ordinances on speeds, but there's no teeth. They have no recourse, really, other than perhaps a citation. And so that's why Happy Valley focused entirely on behavior.

That if… that is, if an officer sees or is reported that there's behavior like Sheila just mentioned.

Um, that's when they go to court. And, uh, not just a fine, but they go to court, and a judge has, uh, latitude to levy a fine, but also confiscate that vehicle.

And if it's a juvenile, the parent has to attend.

From my standpoint, the most important thing is enforcement and penalties.

Del: 100% agree.

Dave: Yeah, careless and reckless operation.

Vanessa: Yeah, thanks. I was just wondering who would enforce these rules.

Dale: The police.

Scott: Uh, in theory, the sheriff, but I can tell you now that it's highly unlikely there would be any enforcement of any of the rules in this ordinance.

Vanessa: Is that because of cost or not enough people to resources?

Scott: Resources, resources and priorities.

Dale: Well, then we're done here. We're done. I mean, if there's no enforcement,  then what's the point of this?

Scott: Well, that's my point.

Del: We never got to the last page of this thing.

If you look at the enforcement and penalties.

What's the difference between B and C?

Scott: Uh, which subsection is it?

Del: The last page, the section 40.

Enforcement and penalties.

Well, what's the difference between B and C?

I don't think there is one. I think that's another mistake.

Scott: It's the same for… it's… well, there's a different number. One is 5…

Del: There's a different number.

Is one supposed to be a first offense and the second one for a second offense?

Sheila: Or possibly one is for 20 and the other one's for 30. The… maybe that's where they messed up.

Scott: I think it's a mistake. I think one of them goes away.

Jim: Yeah, just last comment. I'm sorry, but in section 30, I'm really struggling to find out the difference between subsection a.

It talks about electrical mobility devices and vehicles manufactured for off-road use.

In careless and reckless…

operation, and it goes through subsection ABCDEF.

But then when I go to B in the same section.

It just seems like a blanket statement. The entire ordinance could just sit with that one statement.

Can you go to that one?

7.08… 7.0830B.

Last page.

Scott: So, where it reads, it is unlawful for any person to operate that section?

Jim: Yep.

Scott: Yeah, so I read that to be, that's a complete ban on emotos, is the way I read it. So, do we really, in Clackamas County, want to ban emotos across, like.

Del: Some of the emotos are definitely street legal.

They should be able to operate on highways, but they shouldn't be operating on bike paths.

Dale: That's not correct, Dale.

Del: No?

Dale: Emotos are not street legal. They do not have lights, brake lights, or turn signals.

Del: I think some do.

Dale: Then perhaps we add a definition as to what is street legal. Or copy what's in the state code.

Jim: Yeah, and I think it seems like that addresses almost everybody's concerns tonight. Those are the 14-year-old kids that are running just wild everywhere, and this Section B just says that's a blanket violation.

Scott: That's saying, if you're riding in Emoto, you could get ticketed in Clackamas County.

Jim: It seems to simplify this entire ordinance into one section because that's all of our concern. It sounds like most of our concerns are that.

Scott: How do other people's feel about that provision? Like, is that reasonable to go to that?

Dave: I think careless and reckless operation is the key here. Everything else here is way too prescriptive in a way that is…If you are careless and reckless in any electric device, whether it's an e-bike, a micromobility device, or an e-moto, it doesn't matter. If you're pulling wheelies or you're going back and forth across 

That enables the sheriff, they see it, or if there's a complaint and they come up against it, if they choose to enforce it, to enforce something that is totally reasonable to give them the authority to do so. The rest of this is needlessly invasive, attempting to solve a problem that isn't a problem.

it really comes down to people making it unsafe, either in the bike lane, on the sidewalk, or on a path. And if you give the… if you have this ordinance, that's the one thing that's not…Maybe directly already in Oregon statute. Seems the most logical place to go. Delete the rest of the language.

Scott: So, a lot of that reckless care, a lot of that behavioral stuff is in the vehicle code.

Sheila: I just wanted to ask, does Section 7830, does that include all electric, you know, e-motos, e-bikes? Does it include everything that we see on the street.

Del: Well, not everything, because I think Del made the point about those one wheel, and those guys stand upright and lean forward to go fast?

Scott: So that talks about the behavioral. It's on, you know, I guess my problem with that section is about using, uh, wearing, um, earphones and that stuff.

But the, uh… the other problem is it's straight in from the vehicle code.

It's already in state law.

So, as we've talked about, why repeat it?

So… but at a minimum, the thing about the headphones and stuff should be removed.

In my opinion. Sheila, go ahead.

Sheila: Does the vehicle code currently include electric bikes of all types?

Scott: Well, it defines electric bikes, the one, two, or three as bicycles.

So, it distinguishes them clearly as bicycles. So, it puts them in the category of a regular bicycle.

And it's defined. Now, it doesn't include the other categories, the emotos, the little mini motorcycles, all that stuff.

That's one of the things that I think is there's that gray area, like, where are those? They're… they're so new, they're not in the vehicle code, and they're not… they're just out on the streets.

Sheila: Yeah, one of the reasons behind this might be for education of youngsters that are using these things. I do know that when I ran into the kids on the Rose Creek trail the other day that there were 2 North Clackamas Parks employees there, and so they told the kids they didn't belong there, and she made the comment.

I said something about, you know, Happy Valley has the ordinance, and she said, “I know, but the kids now know where the Happy Valley boundary is, and so they're coming to other places in Clackamas County.

Scott: This came from Commissioner Helm, who lives in Damascus. She brought it up at a business meeting mainly having to do with young people on the mini motorcycles that ride down this, you know, do illegal things, pop wheelies, all the stuff we're talking about, and she then held a study session. I'm sorry. Yeah, a study session. And that's where staff, which was myself, presents the issue to the Commissioners. and then they decide what to do. And their decision was to pursue an ordinance. And the ordinance is what is before you, and that was drafted by county counsel. County Counsel doesn't really have a very clear and defined process on the steps going forward, which is disappointing.

At this point, they're just saying people can show up before a business meeting, and the Board of County Commissioners has a time set aside at the beginning of the meeting for public comment.

So, folks are, you know, you're welcome to go to that.

Speak your piece, say whatever you want as a member of the PBAC committee or as a citizen.

That's what I've been told. The other channel is this, um, the PBAC, and, you know, submitting feedback through PBAC.

You're also welcome to write, you know, if we don't come to a consensus ON public comment to provide, you're welcome to do that on your own as a resident of Clackamas County.

So, then Dave's second question was having to do kind of what to focus on.

Um, and what would be kind of the priorities. 

Well, but 1 point on the enforcement, you know I shouldn't. I'm not speaking for the sheriff, I just know what I've heard from the chair of the county commission, who is the former sheriff and knowing the staff resources and what I've been told in the past about bike-related enforcement issues is that that's very low on their priority.

Dale: In talking with the police and sheriffs in Happy Valley, their issue was prior to the ordinance that they couldn't tell a type one, type two, type three bike. They could not tell the age of the rider, especially if they had a helmet.

That's why Happy Valley focused on behavior, is that it doesn't matter whether… what type of bike it is, it doesn't matter the age of the rider, it's that behavior that they're now able to focus on, and I would like to share that the first citation that was issued in Happy Valley was by a county sheriff, because we have a partnership with our police and the county sheriff. So, the sheriffs wrote the first citation under the new e-bike, uh, ordinance.

Scott: So why would we need an ordinance at all? Because that sort of stuff is already illegal under state law.

Dale: Right, but it's putting the teeth into it as far as requiring a visit with a judge, and the judge has the latitude to either fine or confiscate the bike. I can tell you from personal experience in Happy Valley. That behavior has gone way down. It's not disappeared, but it's gone way down since that ordinance came into effect.

Dave: It's the penalty, Scott. There's an ordinance, but it's not clear what the penalty is. So, it's the confiscating the bike.

That is the effective thing here, and that's not in here. The $250 fine is… It's not insignificant, but it's the…$1,000 bicycle or $2,000 emoto. I don't know how much they cost being confiscated. That is the issue, and that they appear before a judge, then would just pay a fine, and it's all over. I think that inconvenience and the loss of an asset would drive the behavior change

Dale: And requiring the parent to attend as well if it's a juvenile.

Vanessa: I was just trying to get clarification about what we are talking about regarding confiscating a bicycle. Is that a specific… is that specific to the city of Happy Valley, or is that listed in the state rules or laws.

Dale: Currently it's only in Happy Valley ordinance. That's why I'm suggesting it here for the county.

Vanessa: Well, then maybe it could be suggested for the state and then the county doesn't have to have a whole separate ordinance. If the county's just going to follow what the state is doing.

Dale: Having experience with state regulation and trying to get laws changed that it will be a glacial process. To get the legislature to do that, because I believe that's what you have to do, Scott, uh, is unlikely to happen, but to get the county commissioners to do it when one of the county commissioners wants to do it is a much more straightforward process. Their administrative time, their ability to do it is much clearer, much more straightforward, and they have.

Scott: Sheila, you get the last word because we're just about at time.

Sheila: Did County Council look at the Happy Valley ordinance?

Scott: Yes.

Dave: We certainly don't have a consensus on anything to go back and do, and it'd be lovely to be able to do that, but my recommendation to the group before asking for a motion to adjourn is each person has the letter that Scott sent, and my suggestion is you look at that, and if you can make time, and I suggest that you try to do that, to send a letter to the county indicating what you think should happen in relation to the ordinance, and I think maybe that's even more powerful in its own way, or attend the meeting and do it, which I'd be happy to do if I could, uh, could do that

During the day, don't they, Scott?

Scott: Yeah, I can send out in the day after when the day… they're during the day, but I can send you, like, the exact time in the day of the week, and that sort of thing.

You can write your own letter to the commissioners. You can send an email to them, direct their emails on the website or I could send that to you, send an email, a written letter.

go orally testify before their meeting, and I'll make sure to send that to everybody tomorrow.

Sheila: Well, when you said we hadn't come to a consensus, I just was going to mention, I am chair of the North Clackamas Parks and Recreation, and I have an opportunity to speak to the commissioners, and 2 of the incidents that I've experienced have been in the park. So, I just was going to say, if there is some type of consensus, I could certainly mention it when I speak to them. But if we don't have a consensus that would not be, you know, something that I would be able to do.

Dave: Well, I think you, my request is that you relate your incidents and that, you know, you're part of this committee, and you've had this… we've had this discussion. And while we weren't able to come to consensus, I think we all agree enforcement is a key. And the enforcement has to be meaningful to the person that you're enforcing the ordinance on, like what they're doing in Happy Valley. But we didn't come up with any specific recommendation that we could put down. I mean, that's what I would say if I went there, was to say, you know.

As a cyclist who rides on these trails, it's very, I would say, dangerous to have the overtaking by people and the kids on their popping a wheelie, because if they lose control, I go down, I break bones, and they bounce up and go, oh, that was funny. And I'm like, it's not funny when I'm in the hospital.

So… and I think that's really what they're trying to fix, right? And this is just the modern minibike for those of us who are old enough to remember when those were really cool, and you know, you had your motocross bike, and the police struggled with those 50 years ago, just like we're struggling with e-bikes. It's just now that this is an e-motor and not a gasoline motor, so it's just a different problem on a different machine. It's, you know, kids having fun and they think they’re immortal and so they just don't see the world the same way we do until The thing that they're enjoying using is no longer theirs or they're they realize there's a consequence. But until then. They're just kids having fun.

Okay, do I have a motion to adjourn before we beat this further, Scott, thank you for bringing this forward and working on it. 

Dale: Motion to adjourn

Sheila: Seconded.

8:05 p.m. - Adjourn

Staff Liaisons:

Mya Ganzer • Planner 1• Dept. of Transportation & Development (503) 742-4520 • mganzer@clackamas.us

Scott Hoelscher • Senior Planner – Multimodal Transportation  • Dept. of Transportation & Development (503) 742-4533 • scotthoe@clackamas.us