Meeting materials
Attend the meeting
- Join via Zoom
Webinar ID: 840 7974 9992
Phone: 971-247-1195
Free language assistance services are available for this meeting. Contact Darcy Renhard at drenhard@clackamas.us or 503-742-4545 (48-hour notice needed).
Agenda
- Call to order
- Roll call
- Public comment
This is an opportunity for attendees to comment on an issue of concern to the Planning Commission, unless that item is on the agenda for public hearing. Public hearing items, if any, will include an opportunity for public testimony, which will be announced later in the agenda. - Public hearing: ZDO-294, Minor & Time Sensitive Amendments ‡
- Martha Fritzie, Principal Planner
mfritzie@clackamas.us - Jennifer Hughes, Planning Director
jenniferh@clackamas.us
- Martha Fritzie, Principal Planner
- Minutes ‡
Jennifer Hughes - Schedule review
Jennifer Hughes - Other business
Jennifer Hughes - Adjourn
‡ Attachments
Minutes
Commissioners present: Gerald Murphy, Michael Wilson, Brian Lee, Ryan Founds, Jennifer Satter, Scott Cantonwine, Thomas Peterson, Tammy Stevens.
Commissioners absent: Tyler King.
Staff present: Martha Fritzie, Principal Planner; Jennifer Hughes, Planning Director; Nick Hart, Planner II, Darcy Renhard, Administrative Specialist II.
Commission Chair Stevens called the meeting to order at 6:34 p.m.
Roll Call: Ms. Renhard called the roll.
Public Comment: None
Chair Stevens opened the public hearing for file number ZDO-294, a package of proposed amendments to the Clackamas County Zoning & Development Ordinance (ZDO) and Comprehensive Plan (Comp Plan).
Ms. Fritzie introduced the staff report for the proposal. The proposal is for a set of legislative amendments to the ZDO and Comp Plan under the title ZDO-294: 2027 Minor & Time Sensitive Amendments. The minor and time-sensitive packages are typically put together to make sure that our codes comply with State mandates, particularly new ones that have been issued. Other small amendments may also be included in order to clarify existing language, correct errors, and adopt any optional provisions that only require minimal analysis with an eye toward simplifying, streamlining, and making our code more understandable for both staff and the public.
This set of amendments will modify one chapter of the Comprehensive Plan, 27 sections of the ZDO, and add one new section to the ZDO. This is to implement either State mandates or rule changes that have recently gone through the rulemaking process and have an implementation date of January 1, 2027.
Additionally, the proposal will adopt optional regulations for farm stores and associated agritourism events, amend property line setbacks for some accessory structures in the FU-10 District, and correct errors, increase clarity, and streamline some regulations and processes.
Generally, the legislative changes fell into 6 categories: middle housing, single room occupancies (SROs), notification of land use proposals to tribes, designation of significant cultural landscape features, restoration and replacement of certain dwellings that were destroyed or damaged due to involuntary events, and farm stores and associated agritourism.
Mr. Hart discussed the changes to the middle housing and single-room occupancy rules that we are required to make. Beginning on January 1, 2027, we are required to allow the middle housing types that we have now (duplexes, triplexes, quadplexes) in our urban low-density residential zones as either attached or detached units. This means that a quadplex can now be 4 completely separate units. Suddenly some of the standards that we had and that made sense when all the units had to be attached make less sense now that they can be completely separate. We also clarified some middle housing development standards to hopefully make implementation of the new mandate smoother when the time comes.
With the SROs, a similar change has been made. They are now required to be allowed as either attached or detached units, and we are required to allow SROs at 3 times the density of multifamily units where multifamily units are allowed.
These amendments do not propose to allow any more density than the county is required to allow by the new State mandates. The bonus units that are being added to middle housing and the SRO density bonuses are mandates that we are required to adopt.
What these amendments change is how we refer to middle housing throughout the ZDO. Now that middle housing can be attached or detached dwelling units, we have opted to simply state that in urban low-density zones, we would allow up to four dwelling units in any detached or attached configuration, or cottage clusters on a single lot of record. The biggest reason for doing this is because we want to retain the current definitions of “-plexes” in other zoning districts where the middle housing mandate rules don’t apply and where duplexes, triplexes, and quadplexes are allowed . By defining the allowances in distinct ways we are hoping to make the ZDO and these mandates easier to implement. In the ZDO it will show that you can get one, two, three, or four units and one or two bonus density units under the middle housing allowances in an urban low-density zone. If you are in a different zone that does not have the middle housing allowances, you may still be able to have a duplex, triplex, or quadplex. These changes aim to keep the ZDO clear and consistent while still complying with middle housing requirements.
The new rules regarding cultural areas have two components. The first is that the county is required to provide notice to tribes of land use proposals that include ground disturbance and other land use proposals that are outside of urban growth boundaries. The second part is a new allowance that provides for a local, state, or tribal government to apply for landscape features to be designated and protected as a significant cultural landscape area. The nomination and designation does not require property owner consent, so one of these local governments could apply to designate someone else’s property as a significant cultural landscape area. The County would be required to process that application through the Statewide Planning Goal 5 process, which is the same processes we use to protect other significant natural or cultural areas. We have set up the structure to allow for these applications, but we are not creating a new overlay zone like we have for our stream corridors with this package. We haven’t created specific regulations that will apply to properties that are deemed to be significant cultural landscape areas yet because there are still too many unknowns. As these applications come in, we anticipate coming back with another package of code amendments that would include a new overlay zoning district and would include the development standards that would apply to these properties.
The county is now required to allow for the restoration or replacement of a dwelling that has been damaged or destroyed by a natural or involuntary event, anywhere in the County, in any zoning district. The application to replace or rebuild the damaged or destroyed dwelling must be submitted within 3 years of the event, and the dwelling will either need to have been lawfully established, or it needs to have been assessed as a dwelling for the previous 10 years. There are limits on how much larger these replacement dwellings can be, but it is a short list of standards.
The current ZDO only allows the Planning Director the Planning Commission, or the Board of County Commissioners, to initiate a legislative plan amendment. Staff is proposing to amend the code to allow a city to initiate a legislative plan amendment when a city’s urban growth boundary is approved by the city.
Ms. Hughes discussed farm stores and associated agritourism. State law now requires us to allow farm stores in the Exclusive Farm Use zone. We already allow farm stands, but the farm stores are a new use. The mandatory standards require that the farm store be sited on a tract that has a certain amount of acreage in farm use, and it is a sliding scale based on the size of the farm. On relatively small tracts there is an alternative where they can demonstrate a certain amount of farm income in lieu of having a particular amount of acreage in farm use. There is an allowance for a permanent structure or structures for the farm store with a maximum of 10,000 square feet total. Within the permanent structure you can do all of the uses that are allowed for farm stores, including the sale of non-farm products from anywhere in the State of Oregon. It can sell both fresh and processed farm products. In addition, in the permanent structure, a farm store can include the sale of non-farm products up to 25% of the floor area. If a farm store had a 10,000 square foot permanent structure, 2,500 square feet could be used to sell non-farm products. In addition to the permanent structure(s), farm store operations may be conducted outdoors or in temporary structures for any of the farm store related activities, except for the non-farm retail products. A farm store is also allowed to include the sale of prepared foods for immediate consumption. It cannot act as a cafe or a drive-through restaurant, but the language is not clear as to what that actually means. The definition of agritourism activities is fairly broad, but it includes farm tours, educational exhibits and classes, play structures, farm-to-table meals, crop mazes, animal petting and feeding exhibits, hay or tractor rides, and other seasonal or holiday events. One thing the legislation does require is that the activities promote the sale of products from the farm store and farm operations. There is no limit on the number of events and no cap on attendance at the agritourism events. Mobile vending units are also explicitly allowed in conjunction with the agritourism activities. These are what we are mandatorily required to allow under State Law.
The optional allowances for farm stores include standards for parking, access, and egress. Staff is recommending that we apply the standards taken directly from the parking chapter of the ZDO. We have standards for parking lot design, some standards for sight distance at access points, and spacing. For traffic management, there is potentially a requirement to do a traffic management plan from a professional engineer. There are several different triggers that would cause that requirement to be implemented. If they are proposing more than 75 parking spaces, we would require a traffic management plan. Another trigger would be if there is a documented queuing problem. If the County’s Engineering Department is able to document that vehicles are queuing on the roadway to get into the site in a way that violates their standards, we could require them to do a traffic management plan. The third trigger is if they can’t meet the sight distance standards. If their access point is unable to comply with sight distance standards, even after implementing some mitigation measures, then the traffic management plan requirement would apply because of the safety concern.
Noise management is also a concern. Right now, the proposal is to apply a maximum decibel level at the property line, which is the same standard that we have for our home occupations to host events. In addition, staff is proposing to limit the hours of operation. We are suggesting that the hours of operation be more limited for loud activities, specifically amplified music and pneumatic devices like pumpkin cannons. We are also proposing a minimum setback for those kinds of noise-making devices. Staff is concerned that the way the code is drafted, it is hard to discern at what point a noise study would be required. There is a significant cost associated with having a noise study done, so the question is when should a noise study be required? Would it be only for certain types of events? Should those events be limited to a certain number of days?
Staff is proposing to define temporary structures used in farm store activities as structures that are on the site for no longer than 90 days in a calendar year.
Another optional standard related to the farm stores involves hours of event operation. Staff is proposing to allow hours of operation from 8 am to 6 pm Sunday through Thursday and 8 am to 8 pm on Friday and Saturday. Should summer hours be extended, and should hours be different if there are loud events taking place?
The last optional standard is sanitation and solid waste. Staff has drafted language for controlling windblown litter and unsanitary conditions. There are some proposed standards for submitting a plan for waste receptacles and the requirement to manage the waste that these activities would generate. On the sanitation side of things, the proposal is no different than what is already in practice, which is that the Septic Department and Building Codes Program regulate sanitation. The permanent structure itself will be required to have an ADA-accessible bathroom as part of the building code, but there may be additional portable toilets for some agritourism activities. The question is whether those should have a setback or screening requirement from neighbors for portable toilets, if they are provided.
Mr. Hart discussed the remaining items in the proposal. Staff is proposing some changes that are not actually mandated, but that we have elected to address. The first is a change to the way certain setbacks are addressed in our FU-10 zone. The FU-10 district is a sort of transitional zoning district that applies to properties that are located within an urban growth boundary and that have a Comp Plan designation for eventually developing at an urban density, but because services are not yet available either because of annexation or the extension of sewer lines, they are not yet able to develop at the urban density levels. When this code section was adopted, it was given the same setback rules that apply in all of our other rural residential zones. This has come up because of a Code Enforcement situation that was referred to the BCC, so the Board’s office asked us to take a look at the rules and consider amendments that would potentially address the issue. The property in question is located just outside of Oregon City. The intention is for the property to eventually annex to the City of Oregon City and to develop under their zoning rules. It has an Oregon City Comprehensive Plan designation for low-density residential development. For properties that are located in the FU-10 zone that are still in Clackamas County, and that the City of Oregon City has planned to apply a low-density zoning designation to, these amendments allow an accessory structure that is less than 600 square feet in size and less than 17 feet in height to have reduced setbacks to match what the structure would have in the City of Oregon City. The amendment would apply to a relatively small number of properties throughout the County, and all of them are clustered around the City of Oregon City.
The remaining amendments are a bundle of typos, missed citations, formatting issues, and things that raise repeated questions. The biggest one is to increase the maximum allowed flag size from 40 square feet to 47.5 square feet to allow for a military casket flag to be flown where it previously could not. We are also testing a new format for the extensive table of uses in ZDO Section 401 to hopefully make it more usable.
Staff has identified what we think are all of the applicable and relevant goals and policies that need to be met with all these amendments, including Statewide Planning Goals, various Oregon Revised Statutes and Administrative Rules, the Metro Urban Growth Management Functional Plan where it is applicable, the Clackamas County Comprehensive Plan, and ZDO. Staff’s recommendation is that the Planning Commission recommend approval of the ZDO-294 text amendments included in Attachment A to the Board of County Commissioners.
Commissioner Cantonwine asked how prevalent the noise concerns are for agritourism events. Ms. Hughes answered that we typically hear the complaints from the home occupations to host events. Commissioner Cantonwine is concerned about having 75 parking spots trigger a traffic management plan. Ms. Hughes explained that the larger events, such as holiday bazaars, fairs, and similar activities tend to generate much higher traffic than what you would normally see at one of these sites. People may go to the event for a couple of hours and then leave, but when it is happening all day long it generates an unusually high volume of traffic. The County’s traffic engineer provided the 75 spaces as the factor that they would look at.
Commissioner Murphy asked if there is a minimum lot size for 4 units within an urban growth boundary. He has concerns about how all of these dwelling units are going to fit onto the small lots. He asked for clarification on several definitions, and how many temporary emergency dwellings would be allowed on a lot in the TBR zone. He asked if there is a limit on how long a vehicle can park in the parking lot of a farm store and if they are seasonal, or are they 365 days a year? He agrees that there needs to be a sound limitation on the farm events. Ms. Fritzie explained that currently in our low density residential zones, if you were to divide your property there is a minimum lot size based on your density calculation. In an R-10 zone, you must have 10,000 square feet per new lot or per lot that you create. This is not changing. What’s changing is minimum lot sizes for some middle housing types. Currently if you want to build a triplex, you must have at least 5,000 square feet, or 7,000 square feet for a quadplex or cottage cluster but recent legislative changes remove that and no longer allow for any different minimum lot size for any types of middle housing in the low-density residential zones. We now must allow up to a quadplex on a lot that is any size in those zones. It is then up to a developer to figure out how to do that and meet all the standards since we still have setbacks from the property lines, we still have a maximum lot coverage of 50%, and we still have a height limit of 35 feet. At some level we have to rely on the developers to propose something that fits all of our standards, and they will want things to still be marketable. Ms. Hughes said that the uses in Section 401 are not changing, we are just changing the layout of the table of uses to make it easier to navigate. Only one temporary hardship dwelling is allowed on the TBR land. Farm stores do not have to be seasonal, they can operate 365 days a year if they choose. They would not be allowed to operate 24 hours a day if we adopt limits to the hours of operation. An RV could quite possibly be parked in the parking lot all day long during the farm store hours of operation.
Commissioner Lee asked how many parking spaces are required for a particular farm store site. Ms. Hughes said that it depends on exactly what they propose. For the store, we are proposing the same parking standards as we apply to retail, which is 4.1 spaces per 1,000 square feet. For the outdoor area, we would apply the standard we use for the outdoor activities like amusement parks or camps. Commissioner Lee suggested that the code specify what type of engineer can provide the required traffic reports.
There was no public testimony.
Chair Stevens closed the public hearing and the Planning Commission moved to deliberations.
Commissioner Cantonwine would like to have a requirement for some sort of screening or a requirement if the portable restrooms are within a certain distance of either a property line or the frontage of the property. He proposed moving the traffic study requirement trigger to 150 parking spaces and agrees with Commissioner Lee’s recommendation to specify that a professional engineer proficient in traffic management plans provide the traffic study. Commissioner Lee suggested a registered civil engineer proficient in traffic engineering.
Commissioner Murphy expressed his concerns over water protection when farm stores are added to farmland. The activity is being changed from exclusive farm use to retail, so this is not something that neighbors and all those who are trying to restore habitats should have to put up with.
Commissioner Cantonwine suggested that the BCC develop some type of grant program to help defray some of the costs to all of the professional studies that may be required for these permits.
Commissioner Stevens feels that 90 days is a reasonable standard for temporary buildings.
Commissioner Lee expressed his concerns about the noise being generated by some of the farm store activities. Restricting the sound level is a good idea in terms of sound reports and studies, although he does have concern as to the costs involved with them.
Ms. Hughes said that it might be possible to have discretionary standards in these applications. We could ask them if they were proposing to have amplified music, use pneumatic devices, fireworks, or other similar loud things. If they are planning on having them, then we could require a noise study.
Commissioner Peterson thinks that the hours of operation are going to be critical in reducing the impact to surrounding property owners. There should be a stronger way to enforce the noise levels so the neighbors have some recourse in dealing with these if they become problematic.
Commissioner Murphy said that we are talking about resource land that is separated from urban areas for this very specific reason. The activities of harvesting, farming, and forestry are noisy and pollutant. How do we separate what the actual farm is doing as far as farming operations versus what these events are? There was a reason to separate these lands, and rural lands were the buffer zone.
Commissioner Cantonwine moved to recommend that the Board of County Commissioners approve ZDO-294 as presented by staff with the following clarifications: that the parking space trigger be 150 spaces for a traffic study performed by a registered civil engineer proficient in traffic management plans, that there be screening or setback requirements as applicable for the temporary use of portable restrooms, and that there be decibel standards for events where there will be loud activities. Commissioner Murphy seconded the motion. (Ayes=8; Nays=0. Motion passes)
Ms. Hughes provided a schedule update.
The hearing for file ZDO-294 was closed at 8:36 pm.
Translate


